Scoops of Sweetness: The Best Ice Cream Spots Near Stafford and Fredericksburg, VA

Hey there, sweet-toothed friends! As a local REALTOR® in the Stafford and Fredericksburg area, I’m not just here to help you find your dream home—I’m also your go-to guide for the tastiest treats in town! And let’s be real, nothing screams “summer vibes” or “treat yo’self” quite like a creamy, dreamy scoop of ice cream. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, I’ve got the inside scoop (pun intended!) on the most beloved ice cream shops in our area. So, grab a cone, and let’s dive into the sweetest spots near Stafford and Fredericksburg, VA!

🍦Carl’s Frozen Custard – Fredericksburg’s Nostalgic Gem

If you’ve been around Fredericksburg for a while, you already know Carl’s Frozen Custard is practically a local legend. This curbside stand at 2200 Princess Anne St. has been churning out rich, eggy frozen custard since 1947—yep, it’s a Virginia Historic Landmark! They’re the birthplace of the root beer float (how cool is that?), and their vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry custard is pure bliss. Pro tip: their chocolate malts are a fan favorite, and the retro vibe makes it feel like you’ve stepped into a 1950s soda fountain. Just be ready for a line on warm evenings—it’s worth the wait! Open seasonally from mid-February to mid-November, so plan your visit.[](https://virginiavacationguide.com/ice-cream-fredericksburg-va/)[](https://historicvirginiatravel.com/best-ice-cream-virginia/)[](https://patch.com/virginia/fredericksburg/nova-shop-has-best-ice-cream-state-list)

🍦 Tilly’s Homemade Ice Cream – A Flavor Explosion

Tilly’s Homemade Ice Cream in Fredericksburg (Spotsylvania Town Center) is where flavor dreams come true! With 14 staple flavors and over 24 rotating ones, you’re guaranteed to find something that makes your taste buds dance. Think Salted Caramel Snickers, Irish Chocolate Crumb, or even gluten-free and vegan options for everyone to enjoy. Their sundaes—like the S’mores or Reeses Cup Brownie—are next-level indulgent. Locals rave about the Butter Brickle, and the owners are so friendly, you’ll feel like family. If you’re looking for a spot to satisfy your sweet tooth with a side of creativity, Tilly’s is a must[](https://www.reddit.com/r/fredericksburg/comments/1azfdde/best_ice_cream_shops/)[](https://www.yelp.com/search?cflt=icecream&find_loc=Stafford%2C%2BVA%2B22554)

🍦 Blue Cow Ice Cream Co. – Fresh and Fun

Blue Cow Ice Cream Co. at 607 William St. in Fredericksburg (with another location in Stafford) is all about fresh, locally sourced ingredients and flavors that pop! From Banana Puddin’ with caramelized bananas to the decadent Blue Cow Patty (Butterfingers, Oreos, and chocolate chips in dark chocolate ice cream), there’s always something new to try. Their handmade waffle cones are ironed fresh daily, and the family-friendly vibe makes it a perfect stop for a post-dinner treat. Locals love it for its creative seasonal flavors and cozy atmosphere.[](https://virginiavacationguide.com/ice-cream-fredericksburg-va/)[](https://vafoodie.com/best-ice-cream-in-fredericksburg-va/)[](https://bluecowicecream.com/)

🍦 Abner B’s Ice Cream – A Flavor Fiesta

Abner B’s is a hometown hero with locations at 821 Caroline St. in downtown Fredericksburg and Embrey Mill Town Center in Stafford. With over 425 flavors of ice cream, sorbet, and frozen yogurt (80 of them signature!), they’re basically the Willy Wonka of ice cream. Their chocolate chip cookie dough is a crowd-pleaser, but don’t sleep on their seasonal specials. Whether you’re grabbing a scoop after strolling Fredericksburg’s historic streets or chilling in Stafford, Abner B’s is a local favorite for a reason. Plus, their dip-style ice cream adds a fun twist to the classics[](https://www.abnerb.com/)[](https://www.yelp.com/search?cflt=icecream&find_loc=Stafford%2C%2BVA%2B22554)

🍦 Jimmy T’s Soft Serve – Quick and Creamy

For a quick, no-fuss ice cream fix, Jimmy T’s Soft Serve in Fredericksburg is your spot! With over 26 flavors of soft serve (think chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, and more), plus sundaes and shakes, it’s a go-to for families and ice cream lovers on the move. The portions are generous, the staff is super friendly, and the creamy texture is just *chef’s kiss*. It’s perfect for a spontaneous treat after a day exploring the area. Locals say it’s a close contender for the top soft-serve spot in town[](https://historicvirginiatravel.com/best-ice-cream-shops-fredericksburg/)[](https://jimmytssoftserve.com/)

🍦 Fun Time Ice Cream – Stafford’s Hidden Gem

Over in Stafford, Fun Time Ice Cream is a delightful surprise! This spot is all about classic soft serve (chocolate, vanilla, swirl) with a fun twist—they roll your cone in toppings for that extra crunch! Their “blizzard” style treats and banana splits are a hit, and at $5 for a regular cone, it’s a steal. Locals love the retro vibe and the fact that it’s a great stop for a quick, affordable treat. If you’re driving by, don’t miss it—you’ll wish you’d stopped sooner[](https://www.yelp.com/search?cflt=icecream&amp%3Bfind_loc=Stafford%2C%2BVA%2B22554)

🍦 Bonus Shoutout: The Italian Station

Okay, this one’s not strictly an ice cream shop, but The Italian Station in Fredericksburg’s Marriott deserves a nod for its incredible gelato. With flavors like seasonal pumpkin (when available) and a wide variety to choose from, it’s a perfect spot to grab a scoop while enjoying some coffee or pastries. It’s a great option if you’re staying downtown and craving something a little different.[](https://fxbg.com/fredericksburg-ice-cream-spots/)[](https://vafoodie.com/best-ice-cream-in-fredericksburg-va/)

🍦 Why These Spots Are So Loved

What makes these ice cream shops so special? It’s not just the creamy goodness—it’s the community vibe! From Carl’s nostalgic charm to Tilly’s innovative flavors, these places are where memories are made. Whether you’re taking the kids out for a treat, grabbing a cone after a date night, or just cooling off on a hot Virginia day, these shops bring people together. Plus, they’re all locally owned or small chains, so you’re supporting the heart of Stafford and Fredericksburg with every scoop.

As a REALTOR®, I love showing folks around our vibrant communities, and these ice cream spots are just one reason why Stafford and Fredericksburg are such sweet places to call home. So, next time you’re house-hunting or just craving a treat, swing by one of these shops and let me know your favorite flavor in the comments! 

Got a favorite ice cream spot I missed? Or need help finding a home near these creamy havens? Drop me a line—I’m all about helping you find your perfect place (and the perfect scoop) in Stafford and Fredericksburg!

**Happy scooping,**

Your Friendly Neighborhood REALTOR®

P.S. If you’re curious about more local gems or need real estate tips, check out my blog or give me a shout! And for more on Fredericksburg’s foodie scene, visit [vafoodie.com](https://vafoodie.com) or [fxbg.com](https://fxbg.com) for inspiration.[](https://fxbg.com/fredericksburg-ice-cream-spots/)[](https://vafoodie.com/best-ice-cream-in-fredericksburg-va/)